“Taiwan won’t matter in 18 months” is what happens when software people mistake civilization for a SaaS product.
It's one of the most clueless takes I've heard on this platform in months and that's saying something.
Yes, America has semiconductor fabs. Mostly old ones. Really old.
Taiwan has the fabs that matter:
The ones that make every single chip for NVIDIA and Apple and every damn Android and iPhone on Earth and even most of the 1500 or so chips that go in your truck or car.
Without TSMC these companies simply do not exist. Not kind of struggling. I mean "wiped off the freaking face of the Earth and unable to produce a single product" level gone.
As in "worth zero instantly."
Taiwan has:
- Multiple leading-edge giga-fabs
- The *overwhelming* majority of advanced AI chip production
- Dominant advanced packaging capacity
- Dense supplier clustering
- Decades of accumulated yield/process knowledge and the most skilled workforce on Earth to run it all
The US still barely has frontier-scale advanced packaging online. Much of it is literally still under construction and won’t ramp until years from now.
Momos hear “we’re only 1–2 nanometers away” and think semiconductors are just transistor geometry.
No freaking way. Sheer idiocy. The real moat is:
- Yields - Packaging - HBM integration - Substrates - Tooling - Tacit manufacturing expertise - Workforce density - Supply chain coordination
TSMC is not “a fab.” It is one of the most sophisticated industrial ecosystems ever created by humanity.
And no, a tiny Neuralink surgery robot does not mean America can magically reproduce decades of semiconductor manufacturing concentration in 18 months.
Reality is not a podcast episode.
Taiwan remains strategically critical for years, likely a decade+.
This is like saying:
“We’re 18 months away from replacing the global oil system because we built a nice electric bike.”
Chamath: Taiwan Loses Its Strategic Importance in 18 Months
@chamath:
“ We're 18 months from Taiwan not being an important moment of conversation the way it is today.
Why 18 months? Because we are at a point where we're probably 1-2 nanometers away from being able to do what we need Taiwan to strategically do for us.
And so as we scale up our chip fabs, as we get more capacity, and interestingly, there are these orthogonal technologies being developed.
I don't know if you guys saw, but Neuralink was showcasing a machine that is literally operating at the almost nanometer scale to do the brain operations for the implantation, all automatically.
When you have the dexterity and the capability mechanically to make these things, the real reason then is a very different one than what it is today.
Today, it's economic. And if you take that off the table, I think we'll have a very different attitude to Taiwan.”
















